The Scattering of the Primarchs: Was Chaos the Only Hand at Play?

The scattering of the Primarchs—was it the hand of Chaos, a hidden mother’s defiance, or the Emperor’s own plan? This fateful event sent his sons across the galaxy, shaping destinies and setting the stage for the epic clash of the Horus Heresy.
The Scattering of the Primarchs
Advertisement
Continue Reading Below

The scattering of the Primarchs remains one of the most pivotal events in Warhammer 40k history. Common lore holds that the Chaos Gods struck at the Emperor’s greatest creation, scattering his twenty genetically engineered sons across the galaxy.

However, new theories challenge this tale, suggesting the scattering may have been more complex—possibly even orchestrated by the Emperor or by Erda, a mysterious Perpetual who claims to be the Primarchs’ “mother.”

This lore article explores the known lore and emerging theories that raise fascinating questions about who really scattered the Primarchs and why.

The Emperor’s Vision and the Primarch Project

The Role of the Primarchs

The Emperor envisioned the Primarchs as generals and icons who would lead humanity in his Great Crusade. Using arcane sciences and his own genetic material, he crafted these sons, intending for them to embody the ideals and strength needed to unify humanity.

Each Primarch was to command a Legion, guiding humanity’s reawakening and standing as paragons of the Emperor’s vision.

Threat of Chaos to the Project

Chaos saw the Primarchs as a direct threat to its hold over humanity. The unity the Emperor sought posed a danger to the Chaos Gods’ influence, which thrives on humanity’s fractured and conflicted nature.

Thus, the Primarchs were not just powerful warriors but symbols of the Emperor’s defiance against the gods of the Warp.

Theory 1: The Chaos Gods Scattered the Primarchs

This is the version widely accepted within the Imperium. According to this tale, the Chaos Gods, fearing the Emperor’s creations, opened a rift within his laboratory beneath the Imperial Palace.

In doing so, they scattered the Primarchs into the Warp, sending each of the Emperor’s sons to distant and often brutal worlds. This narrative, backed by early Codexes and novels like The First Heretic, suggests Chaos might have influenced some Primarchs while they were lost, setting the stage for the Horus Heresy.

  • Supporting Reference: The Codex Chaos Space Marines (4th Edition) outlines this account, noting that the scattering was an act of “jealous” Chaos Gods thwarting the Emperor’s ambition.

Theory 2: Erda’s Role in the Scattering

A more recent theory, introduced in Saturnine and Valdor: Birth of the Imperium, presents a surprising twist: Erda, a powerful Perpetual and genetic contributor to the Primarchs, claims she scattered them herself.

Disillusioned with the Emperor’s grand designs, Erda acted to prevent the Primarchs from being used solely as tools in the Emperor’s crusade. She sought to give them a chance to grow independently, away from his control.

  • Implications: Erda’s story has led some to speculate that she and the Chaos Gods may have inadvertently collaborated or manipulated each other. Alternatively, some theorize Erda acted alone, and Chaos merely seized the opportunity to taint a few Primarchs during their journey.
  • Supporting Reference: In Saturnine, Erda reveals her role, igniting questions about whether her actions were solely motivated by a desire to protect the Primarchs or if she, too, was influenced by Chaos.

Theory 3: The Emperor Orchestrated the Scattering

The most provocative theory posits that the Emperor himself allowed—or even orchestrated—the scattering. Proponents of this theory argue that each Primarch’s homeworld seemed curiously suited to their temperament and abilities, almost as if chosen for them.

Furthermore, the Emperor found each Primarch at pivotal moments in their lives, implying either foresight or control.

  • Supporting Argument: In The Unremembered Empire, Guilliman suspects that the Emperor allowed or engineered the scattering to shape his sons through hardship, preparing them for the roles they would play. In Wolfsbane, a vision implies that Fenris itself might have been crafted to suit Leman Russ, suggesting that each Primarch’s destination was no accident.
  • Psychic Foresight: Some speculate that the Emperor, possessing immense psychic abilities, allowed the scattering to occur to hide the Primarchs from Chaos temporarily or to shape their characters in ways only the harsh environments of their homeworlds could.

Analyzing the Theories: Motivation and Evidence

Why Each Party Might Scatter the Primarchs

  1. Chaos Gods: Driven by fear of the Emperor’s unifying vision, they would seek to disrupt his plans and weaken the bond between him and his sons.
  2. Erda: Concerned for the Primarchs’ autonomy, Erda acted to prevent them from becoming tools, seeing the scattering as a way to grant them free will and individuality.
  3. The Emperor: Possibly using the scattering as a test, the Emperor may have wanted to temper his sons, preparing them to lead the Great Crusade with independence and resilience.

One consistent mystery across theories is how all the Primarchs landed on human-populated, habitable worlds—a highly improbable outcome if left to random chance. This detail suggests a guiding hand, whether the Emperor’s, Erda’s, or the Chaos Gods’.

The Scattering Unveiled in the Horus Heresy Novels

Horus-Heresy-Books-1-6-Set

The moment of the Primarchs’ scattering is woven throughout Horus Heresy novels, revealed in fragments through visions, memories, and cryptic confessions from those close to the Emperor.

Rather than a single, clear narrative, these glimpses layer mystery upon mystery, leaving readers to question who truly orchestrated the scattering.

Did Chaos alone disrupt the Emperor’s plans, or was it Erda’s defiance or even the Emperor’s own secretive will at play?

Here’s how various novels shed light on this pivotal event:

  • The First Heretic by Aaron Dembski-Bowden: This novel includes a vision where the Word Bearers Legion witnesses the incubation chambers of the Primarchs and the catastrophic warp event that leads to their scattering. It suggests that the interference of the Chaos Gods was involved and gives a glimpse of the Primarchs being taken through the warp.
  • Saturnine by Dan Abnett: In this novel, Erda, a Perpetual and one of the Emperor’s closest companions, claims she was responsible for opening the warp portal that scattered the Primarchs. Her confession provides an alternative version of events, revealing that she acted out of a desire to protect the Primarchs from the Emperor’s grand designs.
  • Wolfsbane by Guy Haley: In a scene where Leman Russ undergoes a wyrd vision, he sees a version of himself that suggests the scattering may have been deliberate or at least influenced to ensure each Primarch landed in a world that would suit their nature. This implies a more controlled hand, possibly hinting at the Emperor’s own manipulation.
  • False Gods by Graham McNeill: In this novel, Horus experiences a vision on Davin where he sees the Emperor standing in the laboratory at the moment of the scattering. Although portrayed by Chaos as if it were the Emperor’s choice, the scene leaves readers questioning if the Emperor allowed the scattering to happen for a purpose.
  • Scars by Chris Wraight: contains a conversation where Magnus discusses the Chaos Gods’ desire for eternal conflict, hinting that they may have anticipated the long-term discord that would arise among the Emperor’s sons.
Scars by Chris Wraight - Horus Heresy Book 28
Scars by Chris Wraight – Horus Heresy Book 28

The scattering of the Primarchs remains a haunting enigma. Was it the Chaos Gods’ scheme, a desperate act of defiance by Erda, or the Emperor’s own hidden gambit?

Each theory deepens the mystery and adds layers to our understanding of the Emperor and his creations. As new lore continues to emerge, the true nature of the scattering—and its full implications for the Imperium—may finally come to light.

The Rediscovery of the Primarchs: A Journey Across the Stars

After the scattering, each Primarch was lost to the Emperor, marooned on distant worlds with no clear path back to Terra. But during the Great Crusade, the Emperor embarked on a relentless quest to reunite with his lost sons, following cryptic hints and visions across the galaxy.

Each rediscovery was a pivotal moment, reuniting a Primarch with his Legion and expanding the Imperium’s reach.

To explore this monumental journey of rediscovery and learn the order in which each Primarch was found, check out our detailed guide on the Discovery Order of the Primarchs.


FAQs

What is the scattering of the Primarchs?

The scattering refers to the sudden dispersal of the Emperor’s genetically engineered sons, the Primarchs, across distant worlds by a mysterious warp event.

Why did the Chaos Gods scatter the Primarchs?

Chaos feared the Emperor’s ambitions and sought to weaken his plans by casting his sons across the galaxy, depriving him of their leadership in his Crusade.

Who is Erda, and how is she connected to the scattering?

Erda, a Perpetual and genetic “mother” of the Primarchs, claims she scattered them to prevent the Emperor from using them solely as tools in his conquest.

Did the Emperor have any role in the scattering?

Some theories suggest the Emperor allowed or engineered the scattering to “temper” his sons, preparing them for leadership through hardship.

Why did each Primarch land on a world suited to them?

This odd coincidence fuels theories that either the Emperor or Chaos guided the scattering, placing Primarchs on worlds that aligned with their innate traits.

How does the scattering tie into the Horus Heresy?

The separation fueled differences and resentments among the Primarchs, which Chaos later exploited, eventually leading to the Horus Heresy.

Why is the scattering significant in 40k lore?

It shaped each Primarch’s unique character, sowed divisions, and ultimately set the stage for the galactic conflict of the Horus Heresy.

Could the Emperor’s psychic powers have influenced where the Primarchs landed?

It’s possible; the Emperor’s foresight could explain why each Primarch’s world suited them, hinting he may have directed their scattering.

Advertisement
Continue Reading Below